File transfer system: how bad is it?
Posted by absorbation on Sun 08 Oct 2006 (11:46 GMT)

Let's face it, Windows Live Messenger as a software is poor and sloppy. Then again I think most of the 'Live' products are turning out this way, but with so many exciting features within the programs we don't seem to care as much. Well here is my mission to improve Windows Live Messenger.

Take the file transfer feature for example, what a great idea. Sends thousands of file types (apart from the blocked ones introduced in MSN Messenger 7.0) to someone over the other side of the world in a matter of seconds. Unfoutuntaly, due to server problems or just bad coding this is no longer happening right.

The feature itself is rather bare, it does not tell you the speed or give you an estimate of how much time is left, just a green bar counting down the bytes. It gives the impression it was rushed, which you don't want in a software used by millions worldwide. However, that is not my main concern with the feature. The main problem is that it looks unprofessional, and is buggy. Here is my small experiment:

I sent a file (a jpeg image) to ten people on my contact list. There was no order, just random contacts down my list. I gave a quick hello message and sent the file their way. Two out of those eight people told me they were never alerted there was a file. I was not surprised by this. I often send files only to find out my contact never saw it. One contact on my list has troubles sending/ receiving files altogether on his account.

This was a small scale experiment (10 contacts is not evidence) but it is common behaviour. I am sure the problem can be pin pointed somewhere, but this file system is very old now, and I have not seen any changes ever since I started using MSN Messenger.

Changing the system should not be too hard, a program called File Transfer Plus! used its own system for years to send files over Messenger. However, your contacts who you were sending the file to would also need it installed. The principle was a great idea though.

In conclusion with this small article I believe the file transfer system needs serious work. It is buggy, looks half complete and lacks that professional touch, I hope others can agree with me and make it a priority for the next feature list for Windows Live Messenger. Hint: Any beta butterflys who want to mention this post on the newsgroups could help. After all this is not a rant, but a suggestion for the Messenger team. Post your experiences and suggestions about the file transfer system if you can please. I end this post with this quote by wtbw:

'It'd be easier to phone you up and read out every fucking byte'

>> Digg this post!

11 comments | 60 trackbacks | Permalink | 8513 views | 533 words

Did you like this news post? You can get all the latest articles at msgstuff.com in your email inbox each morning by entering your email address below. Your address will only be used for mailing you the articles, and each one will include a link so you can unsubscribe at any time. If you have an RSS reader, I recommend you subscribe to the Full RSS Feed

Comments:

Comment by Huh
Posted on Tue 27 May 2008 (08:17 GMT)
if you use windows messenger then you deserve every bug, virus that you get coes it is a trash prog
msn was not so bad but WM = rubbish


Comment by paul
Posted on Thu 22 May 2008 (05:11 GMT)
msn messenger is rather shite i got 7.5 with discovery and its still so boring file transfer is stupid sending a little 50kb picture takes about 45 seconds i mean wtf is with that i cud run 2 the person quicker msn needs an update and fast


Comment by damian
Posted on Mon 31 Mar 2008 (18:21 GMT)
YEAH! WLM FILE TRANSFER SYSTEM S**** BALLS!


Comment by martin sykes
Posted on Wed 16 Jan 2008 (16:05 GMT)
also agree file sending is buggy I usually find I can successfully send and recieve just 1 file before having problems and usually restarting messenger...


Comment by Aleman
Posted on Sun 25 Nov 2007 (09:31 GMT)
I agree with "absorbation", I had a bad experience with the file transfer feature in WLM, too. It automatically sent a file to a friend when I never explicitly told the application to do that.


Comment by Jason
Posted on Fri 08 Jun 2007 (12:48 GMT)
I'm a music producer and I collaborate with other artists online. Most of the times when I send files via WLM my contacts don't see them and the only solution that seems to work if we both restart the application. Instead of adding new features to WLM fix the ones that are already there.


Comment by marzzbar
Posted on Sat 12 May 2007 (11:16 GMT)
Great to see I'm not the only one having this problem. Please MS, fix this.


Comment by panig
Posted on Tue 21 Nov 2006 (09:19 GMT)
Transfering big files.Any Solution for this problem


Comment by Salem
Posted on Thu 19 Oct 2006 (13:52 GMT)
100% agreed. Need an update.

I've just posted a link to this in the Butterfly Newsgroups as well.

~Salem


Comment by aNILEator
Posted on Mon 09 Oct 2006 (14:08 GMT)
Yeah the amount of trouble we've got, the only problem is that MS will probably turn around and say use the sharing folders instead, however they aren't what i'd call great, having to place a direct copy of the content into those folders isn't my sort of great feature, i beleive it should work like via refferal links or something eg an xml file with pointers to all the files you want to share. Sharing Folders are very handy for albums and large files but shite for everything else, ALSO very annoying that if you delete the content from your sharing folder but your contact hasn't you will get it back from them (I experienced this after formatting, i suppose its a nice back up but very annoying trying to tell your contact to remove the data from there)

Good luck with the mission, mabe make a petition even though they do nothing but yeah :-S


Comment by Alby
Posted on Sun 08 Oct 2006 (15:17 GMT)
Totally agreeing there Abs.

This feature has always been buggy, yet it seems to be getting worse and worse.

A update would be necessairy, I'll try and suggest that in the WLM 8.1 newsgroup.


Add Comment:

Your Name
Your Email Address
(Never Displayed)
Your Website
Message



Type the value in the image above
Notify me of further comments