Criticism over Messenger's protocol lack of standards


Posted by absorbation on Mon 02 Mar 2009 (23:09 GMT) (1370 views)
For all of you who don't quite understand the title, the large IM producing software companies i.e. Microsoft and Yahoo! use their own protocol systems to communicate instant messages, an annoyance for developers who wish to make instant messaging a universal application, where popularity resides within the client, not in the network. Jabber is by far the most popular and modern IM protocol used by many applications.

I recently came across a post which details the problem with the likes of Microsoft's way of sending IMs:

For the sake of argument, assume that you have a cell phone and you're subscribed to Carrier A. You then wish to call, or send a message to, a friend who happens to be a subscriber of Carrier B. Naturally, you would expect your messages to get across, otherwise you wouldn’t be able to keep in touch and your provider would be severely restricting you to their network.


Well, this is not the case when it comes to Instant Messaging (IM) Services like MSN and Yahoo because they're not standard. In order to communicate with other people, all members must be part of the same network, and this means that if the network goes down (and it does more than anyone’s liking), everybody goes down with it!



The post highlights a prevailing problem with IM in our modern world. Technology has become about standards. Whether it's the using Bluetooth within phones, or reading our emails, regardless of which software we use. We expect similar services to work in harmony. Instant messaging still does not do this, and a consequence is losing users to other, more convenient methods of communication i.e. social networking.

Why You Should Avoid Using MSN


Did you like this news post? You can get all the latest articles at msgstuff.com in your email inbox each morning by entering your email address below. Your address will only be used for mailing you the articles, and each one will include a link so you can unsubscribe at any time. If you have an RSS reader, I recommend you subscribe to the Full RSS Feed

Comments:


Comment by Christina
Posted on Wed 04 Mar 2009 (23:49 GMT)
Nope I rather use Windows Live Messenger to talk to all my friends to have messages sent through.


Comment by Ross
Posted on Tue 03 Mar 2009 (14:41 GMT)
The issue isn't the client, it's the way messages are sent through it. Wouldn't you want to be able to talk to all your Yahoo!, Skype and Google Talk contacts, from one contact list? Using a standardized protocol would allow this.


Comment by Christina
Posted on Tue 03 Mar 2009 (04:18 GMT)
Windows Live Messenger 2009 isn't shutting down no the hell it isn't and I rather use the Windows Live Messenger 2009 Client to talk to my friends not some stupid Jabber which i dunno what it is or how it works but they aint shuuting down Windows Live Messenger 2009.

Add Comment:

When you post a successful comment please check your inbox where there will be an email containing a link to activate your comment. There are some issues with the comments system at the moment. If you entered any invalid information you won't receive an email.


Your Name
Your Email Address
(Never Displayed)
Your Website
(Not Required)
Message



Type the value in the image above
Notify me of further comments Yes